Sunday, February 12, 2012
Maxim # 9/99: There are No Rules
Friday, February 10, 2012
Why Write? (The Purpose of Scholarship)
(a) Domain Knowledge (The scholar must know the field of his writing);That's a hard ask. Professor Carter admits that it may not be possible to do this all the time and doesn't claim to have done it himself. But his insight provides the critical link between the purpose of scholarship (the advancement of knowledge) and evaluating the quality of scholarship.
(b) Novelty and Non-obviousness (Good scholarship should not only do something different from what past work has done, it should also make claims that are not obvious in the light of past work).
There is a chat-room analogy (akin to Professor Carter's standard) on how to have a smart (scholarly?) persona on the web. Given the anonymity that the internet provides, you can do this by two ways. Enter a chat-room you know. Open your mouth when others can't.
Wednesday, March 23, 2011
4 Things About Legal Writing
There are 4 things about legal writing that makes it special: Words, Style, Resources and Time.
Words - If law is a language, then legal jargon is the kind of vocabulary that imparts personality to this language. Without jargon, it is sometimes impossible to identify something as legal. Legalese is no longer a form now, it is the content.
Style - Why is it that Justice Krishna Iyer uses a different style when he writes a column for newspapers? (Or did I get this wrong – Have I spotted a distinction that does not exist?). Many a times the audience decide the style of writing. A blog post is very different is style from a peer-reviewed journal publication. Your style can be human-readable (here is the human-readable version of a creative commons licence) or otherwise. What you write may be read by clients, lawyers, judges, students, managers and a variety of people who require to be addressed in a particular style.
Resources - Legal writing requires more than a fertile imagination to flourish. Unlike fiction, it requires verifiable resources and references. The resources can be statues, case laws, text books, treatises and the like. Your resource can greatly improve the quality of your writing.
Time - Legal writing is enriched when you do something other than plain writing – teaching, training, practice, counselling. Since most legal writers do something other than just writing to make a living, making time for writing becomes difficult. If you are in academia, there is so much to write and yet so little time to write. In practice, you do a lot of writing in the fire-fighting mode – filing suits within deadlines, drafting agreements on demand, sending written opinions to clients and many other things. Legal writing is a task mostly done for others. Apart from your Will, there’s hardly anything legal that you write for yourself.
These form the what, how, about and when of legal writing. Knowing these elements and learning how to manage them should make legal writing better.